On the field, Michigan is in the midst of what could be a historic season. Off the field, the the focus has rarely been on the team’s success.
If the latest reports are any indication, the on-field and off-field elements of Michigan’s program could be on the verge of clashing.
An investigation into Michigan’s alleged sign-stealing scheme, centered on now-fired staffer Connor Stalions, continues to evolve by the hour, with one update after another adding another wrinkle to the saga that began in October. While more details emerge about what exactly happened and who was aware of it, the Big Ten may be inching toward a decision on whether to punish Michigan during the 2023 season.
MORE: John U. Bacon answers Michigan sign-stealing questions
The Sporting News is tracking the latest updates from the Michigan sign-stealing scandal. Follow along with the newest developments below.
Michigan sign-stealing scandal updates
Friday, Nov. 10
Michigan still awaiting word from Big Ten
According to ESPN’s Adam Rittenberg, Michigan still hasn’t heard about an impending punishment from the Big Ten as its 1 p.m. ET flight looms.
Michigan’s administration has not heard from the Big Ten as of this hour, per sources. The team will begin its preparations to leave for Penn State around 1 p.m. ET. Really going down to the wire with any discipline, which, as several sources noted, isn’t really fair to players.
— Adam Rittenberg (@ESPNRittenberg) November 10, 2023
Harbaugh still expected to fly to State College
Dinich reported earlier on Friday that punishment to Michigan could come around the time the team is expected to get on a plane and fly to Pennsylvania for its game against Penn State. But regardless of when the punishment is announced, Harbaugh’s attorney, Tom Mars, reportedly told ESPN the coach will be headed to State College.
“I’m confident he’s going to be on that plane one way or another,” Mars reportedly told ESPN.
Jim Harbaugh’s attorney, Tom Mars, tells ESPN he fully expects Jim Harbaugh to fly with the team to Penn State. “I’m confident he’s going to be on that plane one way or another,” Mars said.
— Pete Thamel (@PeteThamel) November 10, 2023
Punishment options for Michigan
Dinich has reported the punishment could be anything, ranging from “indefinite suspension to public reprimand or lofty fine.” However, she also reported that there is potentially a limit to what the conference can do without permission from an executive board. Anything more than two games or a fine of $10,000 would require special permission.
Please remember the Big Ten has considered a WIDE range of punishments – everything from indefinite suspension to public reprimand or lofty fine, sources tell me n @ESPNRittenberg … no assumptions. We have to wait for the news, but a suspension is certainly on the table.
— Heather Dinich (@CFBHeather) November 10, 2023
If it’s more than 2 games or $10k, the Big Ten will need special permission from an executive board composed of league reps https://t.co/6Z7jb2zqH4
— Heather Dinich (@CFBHeather) November 10, 2023
Punishment expected on Friday
The college football world will wait with bated breath on Friday as it awaits what Michigan and Jim Harbaugh will face from the Big Ten. ESPN’s Heather Dinich reported the punishment is expected to be announced early Friday afternoon. She noted the team is leaving for State College at 1 p.m. CT for the Penn State game on Saturday.
sources indicate a Big Ten response is coming early this afternoon. Michigan leaves at 1 and flies midafternoon out of Detroit after getting through security checks, per usual routine.
— Heather Dinich (@CFBHeather) November 10, 2023
Thursday, Nov. 9
Big Ten considering ‘range of possibilities’ for Harbaugh
ESPN’s Adam Rittenberg reported there are a “range of possibilities” the Big Ten is considering as punishment for Harbaugh. The possibility of a suspension has often garnered most of the headlines, but Rittenberg reported the conference is also considering a significant fine.
While we wait … although Big Ten has considered a suspension for Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh, it is considering a range of possibilities, including a significant fine, sources told @CFBHeather and me. Public reprimands/fines are common penalties under B1G sportsmanship policy.
— Adam Rittenberg (@ESPNRittenberg) November 9, 2023
Michigan’s 10-page letter to Big Ten released
Yahoo Sports’ Dan Wetzel posted Michigan’s full 10-page letter to the Big Ten on X (formerly Twitter). The letter outlines Michigan’s belief that the Big Ten would be acting too hastily in suspending Harbaugh or levying any punishment toward Michigan before the completion of a full NCAA investigation.
In the letter, Michigan said the university has not had the chance to review all the evidence and respond, which oversteps the due process allowed for Michigan. It said Pettiti should not have unilateral authority to punish violations without first having a completed investigation and then a response from the Compliance and Reinstatement Committee, which would recommend penalties for rules violations.
Michigan noted that regarding evidence, there is nothing it is aware of to claim athletics personnel at Michigan committed the allegations, and said the rule pertaining to electronic recordings of games is limited to the use of field equipment used by the institution for the game it is currently playing. It also said Michigan has not seen much evidence, but rather has just heard a summary of second- and third-hand information.
The letter also said given the use of sign decoding by other universities, there is little reason to believe Stalions’ efforts proved meaningful, and pointed out the teams’ average margin of victory since Stalions was suspended. It said the information obtained is “at most a reflection of information that teams can and easily do obtain through public and permissible sources,” and because of that it is “highly dubious” that Stalions’ observations would have a “material effect on the integrity of the competition.”
Here is Michigan’s 10-page letter to the Big Ten responding to the sportsmanship investigation, reporting with @RossDellenger 1/3 pic.twitter.com/P0oYgIbS67
— Dan Wetzel (@DanWetzel) November 9, 2023
No timetable for Big Ten decision
The Big Ten is reviewing the “lengthy” official response from Michigan and Jim Harbaugh and it’s unclear when a potential ruling might come down, says ESPN’s Pete Thamel. His colleague Adam Rittenberg reported Wednesday that a decision was expected by Thursday.
Source: The Big Ten is reviewing the lengthy written responses from both Michigan and Jim Harbaugh. There’s no indication of any timetable on a decision on potential Big Ten discipline in the case of Michigan’s alleged illegal signal stealing.
— Pete Thamel (@PeteThamel) November 9, 2023
Big Ten commissioner to miss College Football Playoff meeting Thursday
Tony Pettiti is set to be absent from the College Football Playoff meeting set to take place in Dallas on Thursday. That leads to further speculation that punishment could be coming soon in Michigan’s sign-stealing scandal.
Big Ten commish Tony Petitti will NOT be in Dallas for today’s @CFBPlayoff meeting.
— Heather Dinich (@CFBHeather) November 9, 2023
Wednesday, Nov. 8
Ohio State denies having shared Michigan’s play signals with Purdue
Ohio State coach Ryan Day was asked about the allegations that Ohio State had given information about Michigan’s signs to Purdue before the Big Ten championship game in 2022. He denied them forthright.
“I can tell you this right now that nobody here did any of that,” Day said, per the Columbus Dispatch. “We went through and made sure we asked all the questions and got our compliance people involved. None of that came back at all. I can answer very strongly that that did not happen.”
Michigan submits response to Big Ten
In the latest step toward a resolution, Michigan has submitted its response to the Big Ten’s notice of discipline. ESPN reported earlier Wednesday that no ruling from the conference is expected until Thursday, as the Big Ten is planning to “take time to absorb” what Michigan has to say.
Michigan has sent its response to the Big Ten, a school official tells ESPN. Commissioner Tony Petitti now must decide how to proceed with potential discipline.
— Adam Rittenberg (@ESPNRittenberg) November 8, 2023
Yahoo Sports obtained a copy of the 10-page letter sent by Michigan to the Big Ten. Within it, the school warned Big Ten commissioner Tony Pettiti against levying “premature” disciplinary action against Jim Harbaugh and alleged that in-person scouting and sign-stealing are commonplace across the NCAA.
“The conference should act cautiously when setting precedent given the reality that in-person scouting, collusion among opponents, and other questionable practices may well be far more prevalent than believed,” the letter read.
Michigan also included with the letter “two attached documents of Michigan’s offensive and defensive signs allegedly stolen and shared by other Big Ten teams,” per Yahoo Sports.
Conference awaits Michigan response
The Big Ten expects a formal response from Michigan to the notice of discipline by the end of the day Wednesday, ESPN’s Pete Thamel reports. His colleague Adam Rittenberg adds that a ruling is expected to come down Thursday.
Sources: The Big Ten expects a response from Michigan on the notice of discipline by the end of day on Wednesday. Don’t expect any ruling by the Big Ten on Wednesday, as they are expected to take time to absorb Michigan’s response.
— Pete Thamel (@PeteThamel) November 8, 2023
Tuesday, Nov. 7
Michigan says three other Big Ten schools shared decoded Wolverines signals
While Michigan tries to navigate the storm around its program, the Wolverines are also trying to make one thing clear: they’re hardly alone in trying to decipher opponents’ signals.
Michigan has shared evidence with the Big Ten and NCAA showing staff members at Ohio State, Purdue and Rutgers shared intelligence on the Wolverines’ signals prior to last year’s Michigan-Purdue Big Ten Championship Game, The Athletic reported.
Documents breaking down Michigan’s signals for numerous plays were compiled by Purdue staffers ahead of the game based on information provided by Ohio State and Rutgers football personnel, the report says. The person who supplied the documents told The Athletic he spent 10 to 12 hours per week trying to decode signals based on game video and said the practice of sharing decoded signals with other schools is common.
However, the primary difference is Michigan is accused of using in-person scouting, which has been prohibited under NCAA rules for nearly 30 years, to acquire its information.
Monday, Nov. 6
No connection between Buckeyes coach, Michigan investigation
Ohio State coach Ryan Day and his family have no connection to the Big Ten and NCAA investigations into Michigan, Yahoo Sports reported.
A report emerged over the weekend indicating Day may have had some involvement in the probe into the Buckeyes’ arch-rivals, but the NCAA told the Big Ten there are no ties that it knows of between the Ohio State coach and the investigation.
NCAA shares findings with Big Ten as Harbaugh suspension looms
Yahoo Sports reported Monday that the NCAA shared its investigation findings with the Big Ten, noting that the findings “do not connect the in-person scouting and recording of opponents’ sidelines to Harbaugh.”
Still, the conference is considering a suspension for Harbaugh and could hand down punishments before the end of the week.
Yahoo says a multi-game suspension for Harbaugh is on the table, though Michigan is fully expected to fight a ban if one is handed down. It would be Harbaugh’s second suspension of the season, as the Wolverines self-imposed a three-game ban on Harbaugh to start the season amid an NCAA investigation that found Harbaugh lied to investigators.
Saturday, Nov. 4
Harbaugh ‘likely’ to be suspended
According to The Athletic’s Pete Thamel, the Big Ten might be getting closer to handing down a suspension for Harbaugh.
“Over the past few days, Petitti has spoken with the athletic directors, he’s spoken with the presidents, he’s spoken with the coaches. And the next steps appear that there will be some type of punishment for Michigan. The most likely scenario here is some type of suspension for Jim Harbaugh,” Thamel said on ESPN’s “College GameDay.”
MORE: Why Jim Harbaugh won’t find refuge in the NFL
It was reported earlier in the week that coaches were putting pressure on the Big Ten to hit Michigan with some form of punishment, with Purdue’s Ryan Walters publicly calling for action and claiming the allegations are no longer simply allegations.
Harbaugh was already suspended three games at the start of the season, in a ban imposed by the school itself in an attempt to ward off a separate NCAA investigation.
Friday, Nov. 3
Suspended football analyst Connor Stalions resigns
Michigan football analyst Connor Stalions, the focus of the NCAA’s investigation, resigned on Friday night, the university confirmed.
Statement from Michigan (confirming earlier reports that Connor Stalions is no longer with the program): “Connor Stalions resigned his position with Michigan Athletics this afternoon. We are unable to comment further regarding this personnel matter.”
— Jesse Dougherty (@dougherty_jesse) November 4, 2023
In a statement, Stalions’ lawyer said that his client hoped to avoid creating more distractions for Michigan and denied that any Wolverines staffer “told anyone to break any rules.”
MORE: Who is Connor Stalions?
Stalions is accused of buying numerous tickets to scout future opponents in-person, which is against NCAA rules. The NCAA is also investigating the possibility that Stalions appeared on Central Michigan’s sideline in Chippewas gear for a game against Michigan State.
Statement from Connor Stalions’ lawyer, provided to @BruceFeldmanCFB: pic.twitter.com/T1rjzHZwQ1
— Nicole Auerbach (@NicoleAuerbach) November 4, 2023
Stalions was suspended by Michigan when the news of his alleged involvement first broke.
